to Ponder Number 83
In his exiting book, "On Being a Jew," Professor James Kugel warns his readers about three kinds of synagogues that have done great damage to Jewish life. He calls them the "Ceremonial Hall Synagogues," the "Nostalgia Centers" and the "Davening Clubs." (1)
The Ceremonial Hall is a synagogue in which the congregation is essentially an audience. It reminds one of a movie house or a theatre in which the participants come to be entertained by several players such as the rabbi and the cantor. It exists principally for the purpose of solemnizing occasions such as major holidays, weddings, and funerals and bar and bat mitzvah celebrations. The "worshippers" merely "attend" such occasions. They do not come to seek God or repent but to listen to an often overly dramatic cantor or a sermon "to which they listen with the discerning attention of theatergoers marooned in an unwanted matinee." After the service is over the worshippers exchange pleasantries and make observations about the service reminding us of second-rate Broadway critics: "He really had it this morning, didn't he?" or, "Much better than last year, wasn't it?" or even better, "I am glad that they got rid of that fellow!"
is a way to turn the inferior into the important,
The second synagogue is the Nostalgia Center in which the Rabbi is generally the youngest member. A nostalgia center was once a vibrant community, but when the participants become old, it turns into a Kaddish-saying-place in which Judaism is identified with the old and deceased. Its members admire their young rabbi because he represents that which they lost a long time ago. They do not realize the reason for this: when they were young they did not labor to look for ways to constantly revivify Judaism within themselves.
is not about what "was"
And then there is the "davening club," the "prayer club" in which young people come together to "obdavnen," that is to pray by routine, saying words the high quality of which is lost on the praying community. No doubt everybody participates in the davening club and no doubt it is the most authentic of all three places of worship, but how many leave such a service with an uplifting feeling that they were somehow transformed by the experience?
do not step out of the world when we pray,
Nathan Lopes Cardozo
Kugel, On Being a Jew, Harpercollins, NY, 1990.
Reproduction of this essay is permitted when printed in full.
Go to the top of the page.